Hours

Mon.-Thu. 11AM-11PM
Fri.-Sat. 11-12:30AM
Sun. noon-12:30AM

Parking

Free lot

City's Best

Old Bag of Nails Pub   

663 High St
Worthington, OH 43085
614-436-5552
www.oldbagofnails.com

Rating: 3 out of 5  (15 Ratings)   Read Reviews (15)    Rate and Write a Review

Although it's about the size of a garage, this first branch of what's become a successful regional chain still retains its charm. A former hardware store, the aptly named Old Bags of Nails is cunningly decorated with more than 99 cans of beer on one wall, as well as nifty antiques and old photos. The menu has greatly expanded since the place opened in 1986, even though there's still lots of beer on tap to accompany imports and microbrews. Although the British-style fish-and-chips make it a destination stop for fans of cod, coleslaw and fries, this Old Bag has become famous for its burgers, which are made from USDA Black Angus beef. Cooked to order, they include the Pauly Burger, which is topped with grilled salami, Swiss and American cheese, and Italian dressing; the Rustic Burger, covered with melted crumbled bleu cheese and bacon; and Gaylord's Favorite, with bacon, cheddar and barbecue sauce. There are also soups, salads, seafood, steaks and other sandwiches, along with a wide array of starters both standard and unusual, in case you suddenly have a craving for -- get this -- beer-battered pickles.

User Ratings and Reviews Rate and Write a Review

15 Ratings and Reviews

Order by: Oldest | Newest
kwkwli
Review rating 1 out of 5
awful
By kwkwli on 01/28/2007
My girlfriend and I stopped by the Westerville location. The food was aweful. Her medium steak was crispy and I had to cut the black burnt stuff of my salmon to make it edible. We both finished our drinks halfway through dinner (we ate at the bar), but were never offered any seconds. The bartenders it seems was too busy fussing over the restaurant manager who was sitting next too us having a few too many in her own establishment. Definitely one of the worst dining experiences of my 40 year life!!!
user image
Review rating 1 out of 5
will not be back
By abr0041 on 01/14/2007
saturday 14th of janurary arround noon was my first time there. a few people were in the place waitress brought out the wrong order for my sister. she blaned it on the cook. i had the philly cheese steak. the meat was nothing but fat. half of it was uneatable. also the pop was flat.
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
yeah!
By morganpbt on 08/25/2006
LOVE the fish n chips. I usually don't like fish but i get them everytime. AMAZING!
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
AMAZING
By easystreet75 on 03/07/2005
Best place in town to get burgers, other locations are on the corner of nelson and broadstreat in bexley, and in gahanna on mill street