Venue Image

Hours

Mon-Sat. 5-11PM
Sun. 3-9PM

Cross Street

Route 110

Parking

Free lot

Pricing

High ($$$)

City's Best

Blackstone Steakhouse   

10 Pinelawn Rd
Melville, NY 11747
631-271-7780
www.blackstonesteakhouse.com

Rating: 2 out of 5  (31 Ratings)   Read Reviews (31)    Rate and Write a Review

Owned by the Rothmann Group, Blackstone is perhaps one of the first of a new breed of steakhouses that are reinventing a culinary genre. Although this ultra-sophisticated restaurant serves everything you'd expect from a top-notch steak house, such as a 14 oz. filet mignon in sherry shallot sauce, they've also gone fishing and returned with a persillade-crusted salmon with a mixture of panko bread crumbs, grated Gruyere and chiodini mushrooms. Sides are equally innovative and include the traditional but en vogue Brussels sprout, to the more exotic eggplant and miso. There's also a plethora of sushi and sashimi, which slip down with the help of one of the many exotic types of sake, including ''Dreamy Clouds,'' which blends an aroma of rice and red plums, and may actually go nicely with the roasted rack of lamb.

User Ratings and Reviews Rate and Write a Review

31 Ratings and Reviews

Order by: Oldest | Newest
Supermombx
Review rating 1 out of 5
great atmosphere - lousy steak
By Supermombx on 07/11/2008
I've been to blackstone 3 times and with each visit it went from good to fair to plain lousy. My porterhouse which I ordered med-rare, came rare. I sent it back and it just tasted like a cheap steak from the grocery store. I brought a doggy bag home and in better light I saw that it was just full of dry old fat and not good tasting fat. I ended up throwing it out. It was a waste of ALOT OF $$, the only thing positive i can say is that it is a pretty place and they did give me a complimentry slice of cake for my birthday. Stick with Peter Luger's (although I've seen roaches at the one in Great Neck!! I guess that's what gives the better flavor.
Freshnclean139
Review rating 4 out of 5
Review
By Freshnclean139 on 06/11/2008
My wife and I recently had dinner at Blackstone Steak House and I was very impressed by the service as well as the food. Although, we made reservations we weren't seated immediatly. the night we went was on a weekend and the gentlman at the door appoligized to us because he had stated they were over booked that night so the wait was a little long. But once we were seated, the service and the food had made up for the wait ten times over !!! I would recommend this place to a friend...
user image
Review rating 1 out of 5
Very Disappointing
By MUMROCKS41 on 06/11/2008
I think the place is over-rated and over-priced. ' I was very disappointed with my steak dinner, steak was tough! Not going back again!!!!!
user image
Review rating 2 out of 5
Good Service Bad Food
By SHT RND on 06/11/2008
I recently had dinner at the resturant and I found the food ( I had steak my girl had salmon) mediocre. The steak was average the prices were high but the service was good. Great place to go if you want to brag about how much you paid for dinner. Not a great place to go to enjoy dinner.