Venue Image

Hours

Dinner: Sun.-Thu. 4-9:30PM
Fri.-Sat. 4-11PM
Takeout window: Sun.-Thu. 11:30AM-9:30PM
Fri.-Sat. 11:30AM-11PM

Cross Street

San Gabriel and Rosemead boulevards

Parking

Street parking

Pricing

Low ($)

City's Best

Petrillo's Pizza Restaurant   

833 E Valley Blvd
San Gabriel, CA 91776
626-280-7332

Rating: 4 out of 5  (127 Ratings)   Read Reviews (127)    Rate and Write a Review

Way out in the mercilessly hot flatlands of the San Gabriel Valley, wedged between nondescript strip malls and apartment complexes, is a pizza place that has managed to retain the spirit and quality of the Big Apple for half a century. In fact, some people go one step further and claim that this restaurant serves Los Angeles' closest approximation of Sicilian-style pizza. Brick oven-baked and served by the slice, small pie, medium pie or square, it's undeniably tasty, even though you can't stumble over and grab a slice on your way home from the night clubs. Other than Petrillo's Specialty (everything on it) and Petrillo's Pizza Bianca, there aren't any specialty pies, but you can build your own from a standard list of toppings. Pasta dinners and veal, eggplant or chicken parmigiana round out the menu offerings. The dining room is quite pleasant, though it looks like the decor hasn't been updated since the restaurant opened in 1954. Separate but adjacent is a takeout window with a few seats -- the only option available at lunch. The striped awning outside is tattered but still cheerful. -- Lena Katz

User Ratings and Reviews Rate and Write a Review

127 Ratings and Reviews

Order by: Oldest | Newest
Kittypeb10
Review rating 5 out of 5
THE BEST AROUND!!
By Kittypeb10 on 11/08/2009
The pizza here, is the BEST!! You cant go wrong with their pizzas, but that's not the only delicious food at Petrillo's, San Gabriel! I could eat here day after day after day!! The service is GREAT. The girls there are always friendly and answer to you very quickly. I think i might go there tonight!!! YUUUMMMMMMM :]
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
Family Food Favorites
By PeterNz on 03/28/2009
Pizza, lasagna, pasta, fun foods for the family that never fail IF they are well done. Petrillo's has been providing really tasty dishes for a long time because people keep coming back for more. The customers don't go for the free street parking, fancy service or decor they go because they feel welcome and well served their expectations are met. Cheesey pizza, bountiful plates of past and fresh bread. So much better than Chuckie...without the animatronics Wait service can be overwhelmed sometimes but I don't mind waiting for the meals they serve. Their pizza is their signature dish and deserves accolades. How long have they been at that location? I don't but I hope they continue to providefine food and fair prices.
user image
Review rating 1 out of 5
awful food, awful service
By CLCS4311 on 01/23/2009
Nothing good to say, it is awful food and service
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
THE BEST ANYWHERE
By Hjpieman on 10/26/2008
FOOD IS GREAT, PIZZA IS WONDERFUL, SERVICE IS SO-SO, ATMOSPHERE IS NON-EXISTENT, ALWAYS A WAIT, PARKING IS IFFY, NOISY (ESP SCREAMING KIDS), WORTH THE CONS